Peer Review Process

Peer Review Process

KUADRAN: Jurnal Analitika Data dan Ilmu Komputer applies a double-blind peer review process, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from one another throughout the review process. Each manuscript that passes the initial editorial screening is evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise.

1. Online Submission

The corresponding author submits the manuscript through the Online Journal System (OJS), including a separate title page and an anonymized manuscript. All identifying information must be removed from the review file, including information contained in the document properties, to maintain the double-blind review process.

2. Editorial Screening

The editor examines the manuscript for journal scope, originality, completeness, language quality, ethical declarations, and compliance with the journal's submission requirements. Similarity screening is used to support editorial judgment; however, a similarity score alone does not establish plagiarism or determine manuscript acceptance. Manuscripts that fall outside the journal's scope or present substantial quality or research integrity concerns may be rejected at this stage.

3. Reviewer Selection

The handling editor selects reviewers based on their relevant expertise, availability, independence, and absence of conflicts of interest. Reviewers are required to disclose any potential conflicts before accepting a review invitation.

4. Scientific Assessment

Reviewers evaluate the manuscript based on its novelty, relevance, methodological soundness, data quality, experimental design, algorithmic or system evaluation, baseline comparisons, reproducibility, ethical compliance, clarity of presentation, and validity of conclusions.

Reviewers provide constructive comments and recommendations regarding manuscript acceptance, revision, or rejection. Their assessments should be objective, evidence-based, and intended to improve the scientific quality of the manuscript.

5. Editorial Decision

The editor considers the reviewers' reports and may request an additional review if the recommendations differ substantially. Editorial decisions may include:

  • Accept
  • Minor Revision
  • Major Revision
  • Reject

The editor communicates the decision and anonymized reviewer comments to the corresponding author through OJS. Reviewer recommendations inform the editorial decision but do not replace the editor's independent judgment.

6. Revision and Reassessment

Authors must submit a revised manuscript together with a point-by-point response explaining how each reviewer comment has been addressed or providing a justified explanation for any disagreement. Major revisions are normally returned to the reviewers for further assessment, while minor revisions may be evaluated directly by the editor.

Additional review may be required when necessary. Submission of a revised manuscript does not guarantee acceptance.

7. Final Decision and Production

The editor makes the final decision after carefully assessing the revised manuscript and the authors' responses. Accepted manuscripts proceed to the production stage, which includes copyediting, layout, author proof checking, and publication.

Authors are responsible for carefully checking the proofs and reporting any errors or necessary corrections before the manuscript is published.

8. Timeframe and Appeals

The initial review cycle is normally expected to take approximately 2–10 weeks, depending on reviewer availability and manuscript complexity. This timeframe is an estimate and does not constitute a guaranteed review deadline.

Authors who wish to appeal an editorial decision may submit a reasoned appeal, supported by relevant evidence, to the principal contact listed by the journal. Appeals will be considered independently where necessary.