Reviewer Guidelines

Reviewers play an essential role in maintaining the scientific quality of KUADRAN: Jurnal Analitika Data dan Ilmu Komputer. The journal applies double-blind peer review: the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other. These guidelines describe reviewers' responsibilities and the review steps.

1. Before Accepting an Invitation

  • Make sure the manuscript matches your area of expertise.
  • Make sure you can complete the review by the deadline stated in the invitation. If not, please decline promptly so the editor can invite another reviewer.
  • Inform the editor of any potential conflict of interest, for example if you recognise the authors or have a personal, professional, or financial relationship with the manuscript's content.

2. Confidentiality and Ethics

  • Treat the manuscript as a confidential document; do not share, discuss, or use its content for personal advantage.
  • Do not upload the manuscript to generative AI tools or other online services that may breach confidentiality.
  • Do not attempt to identify the authors, and do not reveal your identity in comments or uploaded files.
  • Report to the editor any suspected plagiarism, data fabrication, or other ethical misconduct.

3. What to Assess

  • Relevance to the journal's focus and scope.
  • Originality and novelty, and the manuscript's contribution to the field.
  • Title and abstract: clear, concise, and reflecting the content.
  • Introduction: background, research problem, research gap, and objectives clearly stated.
  • Methods: appropriate, detailed, and sound.
  • Results and discussion: supported by solid data or arguments and related to previous studies.
  • Conclusion: answers the research objectives without overreaching the findings.
  • References: current, relevant, and correctly cited.
  • Language and presentation: coherent and clear, with informative tables and figures.

4. Writing the Review Report

  • Give objective, specific, courteous, and constructive comments; avoid personal remarks.
  • Distinguish between required corrections and optional suggestions, and indicate the relevant parts of the manuscript.
  • Comments may be written directly in the review form or uploaded as an anonymised file.
  • Use the comments-for-editor field for matters that should not be shared with the authors.

5. Recommendation

Choose one of the following recommendations:

  • Accept: the manuscript is publishable without substantive changes.
  • Minor Revision: the manuscript needs limited corrections.
  • Major Revision: the manuscript needs substantial changes and another round of review.
  • Reject: the manuscript does not meet scientific standards or is outside the journal's scope.

The final decision is made by the editor after considering all reviewer reports. See also the Peer Review Process.

6. Technical Steps in OJS

  1. Log in to your account and open the review assignment from your dashboard.
  2. Accept or decline the review invitation.
  3. Download and read the manuscript files.
  4. Complete the review form and/or upload a comments file.
  5. Select a recommendation, then click Submit Review.