Editor Guidelines

KUADRAN: Jurnal Analitika Data dan Ilmu Komputer applies a double-blind peer review process. These guidelines describe the duties and responsibilities of editors in handling manuscripts from submission to publication, in line with the publication ethics principles of COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics).

1. General Principles

  • Editors evaluate manuscripts solely on their academic quality, originality, clarity, and relevance to the journal's focus and scope, regardless of the authors' race, gender, religion, citizenship, affiliation, or political views.
  • Editors keep manuscripts and the identities of authors and reviewers confidential throughout the review process.
  • Editors do not use material from unpublished manuscripts in their own research without the authors' written consent.
  • Editors must declare any conflict of interest and recuse themselves from handling a manuscript when they have a personal, professional, or financial relationship with the authors or its content.

2. Initial Screening

  • Ensure the manuscript fits the journal's focus and scope and follows the Author Guidelines and article template.
  • Check the manuscript's similarity level with a plagiarism-detection tool in accordance with the Plagiarism Screening Policy.
  • Make sure author identities have been removed from the manuscript files to preserve the double-blind process.
  • Manuscripts that do not meet the basic requirements may be returned to the authors for correction or rejected without review (desk reject), with a clear explanation.

3. Reviewer Assignment

  • Invite reviewers with expertise relevant to the manuscript and no conflict of interest with the authors.
  • Set reasonable review deadlines and monitor progress; send reminders or assign replacement reviewers when necessary.

4. Decision Making

  • Consider all reviewer reports carefully; when recommendations differ, the editor may seek an additional reviewer's opinion.
  • Make an editorial decision: Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Reject, in accordance with the Editorial Decision Policy.
  • Communicate the decision to the authors clearly and courteously, together with the reviewers' constructive comments.
  • Check revised manuscripts to ensure all comments have been adequately addressed.

5. Copyediting and Production

  • Copyedit and lay out the manuscript according to the journal's house style.
  • Send galley proofs to the authors for checking before publication.
  • Ensure metadata, DOI, and article files are complete and correct before the article is published.

6. Handling Ethical Issues

Suspected misconduct (plagiarism, data fabrication or falsification, duplicate publication, authorship disputes) is handled according to the Allegations of Misconduct procedure and COPE guidelines. Where necessary, the editor may publish a correction or an expression of concern, or retract the article, in accordance with the Publication Ethics.